• Fur Affinity Forums are governed by Fur Affinity's Rules and Policies. Links and additional information can be accessed in the Site Information Forum.

Important: Forum Closure, FA Discord Coming Soon

Flamingo

Moderator
Moderator
Administrator
Staff Member
Another objection I have with the idea of replacing the forum with a discord server is that moderation power will be taken from FA staff. Sure, they can "Own" their server and add "Administrators" but Discord staff will always loom like a shadow over the server, they own the server, they will have unregulated access to all messages and "Private" DMs. Discord has less accountability than FurAffinity does because FurAffinity is not a giant faceless corporate entity, they have a much smaller userbase. Not to mention that spam will be a worse problem with Discord, as spambots that sneak in will be able to message members based on the members own DM preference, which is set to allow public DMs by default. I believe that this will actually expose more members to being vulnerable to spam.


Spam is super bad on the forums, I just delete it all. ~ 50 or so accounts every morning. o_O

Discord has a robust automated bot system for defense.
 

Flamingo

Moderator
Moderator
Administrator
Staff Member
Foxy over here putting frowny faces on everything, even my heartfelt goodbye. :( okay Foxy gosh.
 

luffy

Administrator
Moderator
Administrator
Staff Member
Another objection I have with the idea of replacing the forum with a discord server is that moderation power will be taken from FA staff. Sure, they can "Own" their server and add "Administrators" but Discord staff will always loom like a shadow over the server, they own the server, they will have unregulated access to all messages and "Private" DMs. Discord has less accountability than FurAffinity does because FurAffinity is not a giant faceless corporate entity, they have a much smaller userbase. Not to mention that spam will be a worse problem with Discord, as spambots that sneak in will be able to message members based on the members own DM preference, which is set to allow public DMs by default. I believe that this will actually expose more members to being vulnerable to spam.
I built the Discord and chose the moderation tools and Flamingo and I are both moderating it. Every single thing is logged. You can change that privacy setting per server. You should see the amount of spam we filter through daily here, lol.
 

luffy

Administrator
Moderator
Administrator
Staff Member
The title post says they're going readonly at the start of next year, so to me that says yes, they'll still be accessible.
This won't be permanent as it causes the same issue of not providing ROI, but it will be readonly for a good amount of time.
 

RamblingRenegade

Just a Horse Trying to Avoid Life's Manure
People must have a Forrest Gump IQ if they think everyone wants to use discord EFF discord
 

Lutro

Writer
This won't be permanent as it causes the same issue of not providing ROI, but it will be readonly for a good amount of time.
Will there be some offline/downloadable archive available? Even if it's not hosted here (so that site costs don't skyrocket etc). Don't know if this forum system supports that, but I am curious all the same.
 

Valery91Thunder

Slasher Movies & Devil's Music
I built the Discord and chose the moderation tools and Flamingo and I are both moderating it. Every single thing is logged. You can change that privacy setting per server. You should see the amount of spam we filter through daily here, lol.
Is the Discord already up? Or will it be online after Jan 1st?
 

FitzOblong

FitzOblong#9993
Cool! Me and plenty of other just came here and settled in, and now it's pretty much gone, thats great news! (Not)

I just downloaded Discord yesterday, and it is clearly no replacement for a forum. It nothing more than a chat program, with a few suggested topics. Gone are Threads, where a commiunitiy can work on just one topic, it will be a mess!

... Just handling the automated spam that hits the forum alone can be a lot (and costly, too, as we subscribe to an automated service that removes most of forum spam).

Spam is super bad on the forums, I just delete it all. ~ 50 or so accounts every morning. o_O

Discord has a robust automated bot system for defense.

Doesn't the FA forum hand-verify the accounts that get registered? I remember that I had to wait before I could post something, so how is this even possible?
 

ssaannttoo

Joy Boi
The title post says they're going readonly at the start of next year, so to me that says yes, they'll still be accessible.
That was my thought, but wether the resources jnto maintaining that will soon get pulled. I dunno.
 

luffy

Administrator
Moderator
Administrator
Staff Member
Will there be some offline/downloadable archive available? Even if it's not hosted here (so that site costs don't skyrocket etc). Don't know if this forum system supports that, but I am curious all the same.
Unsure, but can definitely look into it. We want to retain what we have, but we also want to modernize and make moves that make sense as a community-based business.
Is the Discord already up? Or will it be online after Jan 1st?
It's "up" but staff-only at the moment. It'll be released on New Years.
 

ssaannttoo

Joy Boi
Cause I think the big thing about a forum is that it shouldn’t have loads of active members. Most of the members should come from not logged in accounts. Most of FA users don’t have a FAF account and come here with questions, see a past asked question that they had and they move on. Rarely would artists want to use FAF to get comms because their art is their ad. People wanting artists should also do the same. I also think it’s unfair to compare a message platform to a porn platform. WITH THE NUMBER OF TIMES I WANK IN A DAY.
 

luffy

Administrator
Moderator
Administrator
Staff Member
I just downloaded Discord yesterday, and it is clearly no replacement for a forum. It nothing more than a chat program, with a few suggested topics. Gone are Threads, where a commiunitiy can work on just one topic, it will be a mess!
I think you need to use Discord more before complaining. Lmao. It has forums and I've made plenty in it so that users from the forums could still communicate in that style.
 

RamblingRenegade

Just a Horse Trying to Avoid Life's Manure
I think you need to use Discord more before complaining. Lmao. It has forums and I've made plenty in it so that users from the forums could still communicate in that style.
Used it discord basically sucks
 
D

Deleted member 160950

Guest
I'll probably go semi active on the main Furaffinity site once the forums die.
 

RamblingRenegade

Just a Horse Trying to Avoid Life's Manure
Yeah I know I won't be active on FA main page as much either now
 

RamblingRenegade

Just a Horse Trying to Avoid Life's Manure
I'm just glad I didn't take the plunge to pay for fa plus decision made now
 

luffy

Administrator
Moderator
Administrator
Staff Member
Failing to see the connection between the main site and the forum other than using it as something to threaten us with because you're upset the forum is going away. The communities between the main site and forum, and how each operate, are completely different. FA+ also has nothing to do with the forum other than ads.

Anyway, if anyone earnestly wants to see more of the structure of some of the forums we've created in the Discord, let me know. It might help ease some.
 

luffy

Administrator
Moderator
Administrator
Staff Member
Other then discord.

What other furry forums exist out there? FAF cant be the only one. Maybe its possible for people who dont use, or dont like discord to migrate to another forum.

If this is closing and there is nothing we can say or do to change that fact. Maybe a migration could be a good compromise
There is also the option of spinning up your own forum for free.
 
Top