Give the fur above you a new tail!

[Keefur]

You get a nice golden retriever tail, since you are not a cat.

 

[ShadeSoul]

You get a rebellious chimera tail!

(Art is not mine, I sincerely apologize if this is from anyone here)

 

[Fallowfox]

Puffy bun tail!

 

[Herdingcats]

You get a pig's tail.

 

[redhusky]

You get a pig's tail.

I give you one of those double fox tails that you can fly with like Tails has!

 

[DireWolfJ4]

Imma give you a golden retrievers tail owo

 

[Simo]

*gives you a possum tail*

 

[Frank Gulotta]

You got a cocktail. It's a liquid, alcoholic tail

 

[Faustus]

You get a 'tail'

 

[TheCynicalViet]

You get a xenomorph tail!

 

[Herdingcats]

You get an eel tail.

 

[Doodle Bunny]

A scorpion tail for you!

 

[Fallowfox]

Squirrel tail!

 

[Simo]

Rend Panda Tail:

 

[KiokuChan]

You get one of those unusual little bulldog knots:

 

[Fallowfox]

You just get a big bull's eye on your butt.

And you're at an archery range!

 

[Faustus]

Oooh that was mean! Just for that, your tail is now a pool noodle!

 

[KiokuChan]

You have a pretty koi fish tail. Keep it nice and moisturized!

 

[WolfSpark]

hmmm *gives you an extra tail with the 4 tails :3 lol.

 

[Fallowfox]

Curly piggy tail.

 

[creamyfox]

Horse tail

 

[KiokuChan]

A flag with whatever you want on it.

 

[metatherat]

You get the tail of Alduin the World-Eater. He gets really pissed off and strongly wants it back, even though he tries to act all casual about it.

 

[Stray Cat Terry]

How about the anaconda tail from movie series-Anaconda?

If I know right, the tip looks like a machete....

 

[Herdingcats]

You get a dugong tail.