Opinions?

[DrPepperAddict]

I have had my sona for about a year and I prefer natural looking sonas more often than not because neon green foxes get old. So when I made mine, I went for a more natural look and also incorporated parts of irl me (spot placement lines up with my irl skin condition and hair type/color)
So I have a cow with brown spots. No big deal and I love her, but lately I was thinking 'what if i had made her pink? would I have become as attached with such an unnatural look? would more/less people like her? would I have a better shot in freebie threads?'
granted the last one is shallow and stupid.
but 'd like to know what you guys think for shits n giggles, which version of Pepper do you like more?

 

[FrostHeart]

The brown would be ok by me if it was a bit lighter shade. Still, nice artwork.

 

[ZELPHINA]

Natural all the way!! Stay true to you and what you like! It's your fursona after all, and if you aren't happy with her, then what's the point?

 

[TheCynicalViet]

Honestly, brown hair looks nice but I'd say to lower the saturation on the spots. Do what you did for pink but for brown.

 

[pilgrimfromoblivion]

I like the brown version better, i guess natural just feels right compared to neon green foxes.

 

[Punji]

I'm one for more natural colouration as well, but I think I actually prefer the pink a little more. It pairs nicely with the light main color.

Maybe a lighter shade of brown would also be nice?

 

[Arix]

Like others, I prefer the more natural look. Always have.

 

[PercyD]

I also like the brown-

But giving her some pink features might be cute. (inner ear, nose, maybe a few discoloration spots)

 

[DrPepperAddict]

I don't know what to say to be honest. Thank you for the opinions!
I feel less unsure about my choice now, and the reminder to keep the pink inner ear when I forget.
Thank you every one <3