I'm going to side with my captain and bosun. Pirates. YAAARRR.
Touhou girls win anyways. I'm afraid no pirate or ninja would have no chance against Remilia.Well if we're comparing ninjas like Ryu Hayabusa to pirates, then ninjas won hands down. But if we're comparing Naruto style ninjas? Lol, not only do pirates win, but so do ponies, Sonic fan characters, and Touhou girls.
Common Gibbs you can do better than that!
Ninjas have better weapons, at least in the fun side. Who wouldn't wanna throw a knife shaped like a star? I know I would, and have!
Yeah, but only one shot before it has to be reloaded, as well as sluggish and inaccurate. A sneaky ninja has a very good chance of being able to get up close to a pirate in that scenario, and when that happens, pirate is going to get cut up.But even then the pirates have flintlocks and stuff.