I know this game is a little obscure, but among rhythm game enthusiasts, Rock Band 3 has the greatest video game setlist of all time.
Just...
NO!
While Guitar Hero had a nice mix of recognizable songs and hidden gems, everything in Rock Band 3 is either painfully obvious music that everyone has already heard to death by now or random obscure crap with AT BEST niche appeal. While I actually liked most of the songs in the Guitar Hero games, I liked about five songs in this 80 song setlist. I liked NONE of the Punk songs, despite punk rock being one of my favorite genres of music, the supposed Heavy Hitters are so obvious and overdone to the point of talking down to the player, there's virtually no Alt Rock despite the game being heralded is having a little for everyone (the same critics criticized Guitar Hero 5 for having a varied setlist, yet praise Rock Band 3), very few of the songs have energy to them oh, and the ones that do have energy are usually, again, painfully obvious and overplayed or poorly constructed, and I also love how it takes the absolute worst songs from Guitar Hero. Hey Man, Nice Shot!? Lasso!? In The Meantime!? 20th Century Boy? Also, RB3 RUINED One Armed Scissor for me, somehow. They added weird Harmonies that made the song sound jarring and the "CUT AWAY!!!"s that were subdued in Guitar Hero World Tour are more aggonized and obnoxious in Rock Band 3.
Now don't get me wrong, the set list isn't all bad. I did like a few songs like Dead End Friends, The Con, Beast And The Harlot and a couple of others, and some of the songs have notes of Competency that could have been better like Viva La Resistance, Living In America by The Sounds and a few others, but then you get turds like Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before, Outer Space, Last Dance by the Ravonettes, Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots Part 1, etc. Songs that all have a similar, emotionless feel to them that will appeal to almost no one and feel like they were added purely as filler. Also, unpopular music opinion but... I @#$%ing HATE Freebird.
Overall, I'd say not only does the game NOT have the best rhythm game setlist, it honestly has the WORST one.