Re: What is with all of this "My little pony" stuff? (The unofficial official MLP Thr
I`ve just noticed something.
Everything the brony fandom is, its basically what the Sonic fandom was. People have OC's, they make fan videos of it, write fan fiction, and they ship characters together, regardless of whether or not it makes sense. Only difference is that the pony fandom is actually liked by people who aren't a part of it.
Are we talking about somewhere between 12 and 14 years ago? When Sonic & Knuckles, for the Genesis, was still rolling, Sonic CD was all epic, and SatAM Sonic cartoon was running? I was all "WEE SONIC!" and get onto the internet into some Sonic-related Beseen chat. It was good, but it wasn't even remotely proportional to the Pony fame. That fandom was really tiny then actually. J. Axer was one of the most talented (only talented?) Sonic fan artist at the time.
Or are we talking about after that, when everything Sonic-related really started sucking? A lot of the old fans (J. Axer included) got bored and abandoned the fandom, noticing the downhill slope SEGA put Sonic stuff on. I actually have no idea how the fanbase expanded at this point.. it sure wasn't because any official Sonic releases were any good. Not notably, at least. (Sonic Adventures may have been an entertaining play, but the plot and voice acting was garbage.)
The Brony fandom can be related to the Sonic fandom (even in it's prime) only after you remove most of the talent. I say this as someone who was there, and liked Sonic. 99% of user-generated content sucked badly, and rather than exaggerating, I'm pretty sure 1% is being generous.
--
That MAD TV spoof was nice. It wasn't really very funny at all, but it was surprisingly supportive of MLP and it's fandom. I can't really say anything bad about it.