That's quite the assumption yourself, as I have never made such a claim.Well no, you seem to be assuming that good and evil, like all who make these arguments, are not dependent on circumstances or that our understanding of good and evil can't change based on the discovery of new values.
It is abundantly clear that you and I have very different ways of communicating the same idea, whether or not you are actually aware of it. I'm rather surprised that you haven't already clued in yourself.This doesn't mean morals are simply subjective, but it means that morals are certainly circumstantial; that is to say, you can often find yourself in a situation where something that would be strictly considered evil under normal circumstances, like killing someone, would be morally justifiable if that someone was attempted to murder you or someone else. Or perhaps you're in a situation where there are simply no good decisions left to make, and you're only stuck with wrong decisions, and the only "right" decision is to choose the least wrong choice; then all you can do is look back and think how did you get to this point?
Again, I have never made such a claim, and as much as I find it amusing that you're willing to lump me together with BahgDaddy of all people over this on the grounds that the both of us respectfully disagree with you, it does leave me wondering if that's the same degree of care you put into discerning good and evil for yourself. Suffice to say, I'm not impressed.It seems the argument you and Bahgdaddy is making is that the concept of good and evil allows for more evil because of it's vague nature, but that's not necessarily true. Good and evil aren't too vague, it's only as vague as the people pretend it is; otherwise it seems pretty clear to me that in most situations and levels of analysis, you can figure out pretty easily what is good or evil in circumstances, it takes minimal analysis usually.
That's what strange bedfellows are for.Never expected to get lumped in with you, Bronze Dragon.![]()
That's what strange bedfellows are for.![]()
That's what strange bedfellows are for.![]()
THIS IS NOT A DEBATE TOPIC! If you want to debate, make your own thread!
What is your faith/doctrine/religion/guiding philosophy (if any?)
Norse & Native American combo. Sweet! Hate to meet you on the opposite side of a battlefield!Pagan. I do tend to have a bent towards Norse and Native American, (the latter because it is my heritage) but I incorporate from many different systems in my own practice. I go to a circle once a month that does something similar, and it is always amazing the community and togetherness that happens when so many different views work together. Lots of Wicca brought in.
Norse & Native American combo. Sweet! Hate to meet you on the opposite side of a battlefield!