Chaotic Neutral Wreckage
Does it look like I was making fun of them? I was simply pointing out their flawed logic. Because hey, you were put into a human body for a reason.
As said prior, not all therians are spiritually identifying. It could be due to psychological reasons.
What you said essentially tallies up to; If you experience dysphoria, kill yourself.
Do you believe the same for Trans individuals?
How about those who have physical deformities and wish for different circumstances?
It's incredibly insensitive to rule it all under one definition and then imply a group should shoot themselves to solve the issue. Especially if the core struggle of that group (general dysphoria) is experienced by several other groups (the trans community, those with physical deformities, those who survived wars and are now missing limbs they wish they had, etc). You might not see it as that extreme because to you, it's just some morbid humor making fun of weird people on the internet, but to me...it comes across as a much more pointed statement towards anyone with Dysphoria. It's rather cruel of you.
What do you mean? I was never implying to kill myself or to encourage someone else.
To quote you from earlier...
If one would literally believe that they are an animal spirit that somehow got transferred into a human body, wouldn't it make the most sense for the to kill themselves
This is basic Evasion tactics in Ethics.
While you didn't directly state, "You should kill yourself" you phrased it in a question that implies your thoughts on the subject. Stating otherwise is a way to take off the guilt or responsibility from what you said, but anyone reading would know and understand the implication.
Even if you didn't think this and you were just asking for theoretical or philosophical reasons anyone with social intelligence and a bit of psychological knowledge would know the implications of such a question, and how others might take it. It goes beyond asking an "innocent" question, and I'm pretty sure you're smart enough and/or old enough to understand why that is.
But hey, let's assume you didn't mean any of that and just thought stating the question would be a constructive addition to the conversation...in my opinion, bringing up suicide in any context likely isn't a good idea unless the topic itself is about suicide. I doubt anyone discussing general reincarnation theory wants to hear the addition of, "Why don't people who believe in coming back shoot themselves and save themselves the time or trouble of living this life?"
Even outside of the OP's topic, it's just...extremely out of nowhere, incredibly rude, and very easy to misread.
I hope you can understand why Tyra wanted to provide that addition to let others know not to take it seriously.